One of the most costly hiring mistakes I’ve made involved someone with an excellent track record.
I’ve since watched other smart leaders make the same mistake. And with several of my partners making key hires right now, it’s been on my mind.
I remember studying a case in business school that helped me understand why this happens.
In 2011, JCPenney hired a superstar executive to save its struggling business.
It was a disaster.
Ron Johnson had spent the previous decade at Apple, where he’d helped build one of the most successful retail operations in history. Before that, he’d been a senior executive at Target.
And JCPenney desperately needed someone good: sales were declining, stores were outdated, and the company was struggling to compete. With Johnson, hopes were high.
Johnson wanted to transform JCPenney into a shopping destination, much as he’d done at Apple. He introduced branded shops within stores, simplified pricing, and eliminated most of the coupons and promotions that had defined JCPenney’s business for decades.
The year before Johnson came, JCPenney had run nearly 600 sales and promotional events. Johnson cut that number to 12, replacing constant discounts with lower everyday prices.
Why make customers hunt for coupons when you could just offer them a fair price?
But there was a big problem. Turns out JCPenney’s customers liked hunting for coupons. They enjoyed finding bargains. Many of them weren’t convinced they were getting a good deal without a big discount printed on the price tag.
Apple’s customers were distinct. They were willing to pay more for a premium product and shopping experience. JCPenney’s customers did not like what Apple customers liked.
In 2012, JCPenney’s sales fell nearly 25%, and the company lost almost $1 billion. Shortly thereafter JCPenney’s board fired Johnson.
Here’s the mistake I’ve made, and that I suspect JCPenney’s board made, too: hiring someone because of WHAT they’d accomplished without understanding HOW and WHY they’d accomplished it.
I’ve seen superintendents, principals, and nonprofit leaders hired on the basis of success in a prior role. Then the new leader tries to duplicate the same instructional program, budget process, or board management approach that worked in their last setting, and it blows up in their face.
Here are three questions to consider when evaluating whether someone who has succeeded in the past is likely to be able to translate that success to a new context:
- How did the candidate determine what would work best for the people they were serving?
- How did the strengths, weaknesses, and resources in their prior role shape their strategy?
- Can they break down what would make duplicating what they did in the prior context hard or impossible in another setting?
I used to put a lot of stock in the idea that past success is the best predictor of future success. I still think track record matters. But now I want to know if someone can start with the people they’re serving and the results they’re after, and then organize the available time, talent, and money to yield those results.
(By the way, these are also good questions when hiring a consultant. Some run a playbook without much of a diagnostic or discovery process.)
Rooting for you,
Rob

