Why Nonprofits and Schools Need to Define the Problem Before Choosing Solutions

Last week, I had two opportunities to talk about a common pitfall I see across foundations, schools, and nonprofits: choosing a solution before clearly defining the problem we’re trying to solve.

I had a letter to the editor published in The New York Times and was a guest on a podcast, The Nonprofit Show (YouTube, Spotify).

In my letter, I challenged the idea that we can rank interventions for improving schools without understanding the particular students and circumstances in which those interventions will be used.

On the podcast, I talked about how nonprofits can end up pursuing a collection of disconnected programs in response to funding opportunities.

Consider a community center whose goal is to help elementary school students who are behind in reading catch up before middle school.

A board member offers to fund yoga classes. A grant becomes available for after-school science labs. Another donor wants to support a community garden.

All three offer something valuable to students. But none directly addresses the reading skills those students need to develop.

Now the center has more programming, more demands on its staff, and less time available to help students achieve the stated goal.

The pressures facing school systems and nonprofits differ, but the underlying mistake is remarkably similar.

Leaders feel pressure and move from a broad, worthwhile goal to a specific intervention or solution without getting specific enough about the students they’re serving and what those students need to succeed.

Before adopting another intervention or adding another program, I encourage leaders to ask three questions.

FIRST:

1.Who are the specific students we’re trying to serve?

2. What outcome are we trying to help them achieve?

THEN:

3. How, exactly, will this program help those students achieve that outcome?

If we can’t answer the first two with confidence, we’re not ready to evaluate the potential of a given solution.

And at the end of the day, the most expensive solution is the one that doesn’t solve the problem.

Rooting for you,
Rob


Share this LinkedIn Facebook X Email
en_USEN
Scroll to Top